The mother-daughter relationship, good or bad, is a reflection on two generations not … Researchers hypothesize that mother-blame has functioned as a form of societal control, a way to name and reinforce the status quo. Whatever the issue, it always pointed back to the mother. Genesis to St. Augustine to particularly the twentieth century. I don't want to be a dictator. Myth #1: The measure of a good mother is a "perfect" daughter. The mother-daughter relationship, good or bad, is a reflection on two generations not just one. Additionally, these women seem to also have a different set of expectations of how the world should treat them as moms the then men who do the same job. By Ruth Colker. But still the horrible Refrigerator Mother theory persisted for some time. No doubt, some are playing the role of martyr. "She kept the family anchored through their daily meals and inexpensive family outings. In more recent work, Smith has also argued that in some cases, say in “the reactions of a mother whose son is blameworthy for [a] crime” (Smith 2013: 35), the relevant belief-desire pair might be present without blame. At the close of the 19th century, Freud theorized that, like the mythical Greek king of Thebes, a child unconsciously wants to kill off his father so that he can have sex with his mother. This idea of blaming the mother is the stock of many myths and has a long history from . I noticed this when my children were very young and we would go to the parks and playgrounds; moms bitch so much about taking care of their kids. Fathers have gone to war or are working long hours. Very much agree that mothers (and patents in general) that put in so much effort should not be put down and should be helped/respected in what is societies toughest and yet most important job. Article . Your use of the site indicates your agreement to be bound by our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. “For most people, Bettelheim is a historical footnote, but my family and I lived this terrible era firsthand. Current research indicates that genetic factors are suspected in the … Professions that use skills akin to those of mothers are paid less and mother's work garners a low fee when it comes to divorce cases. Attachment theory is attractive because Americans want to believe two things: That what happens in the opening years is critical and that a mother’s love has a special power, more than a father’s love. Article. Kelsi Toews, Jorden A. Cummings, and Jessica L. Zagrodney. "I was on my own for ten years with them -- my oldest son was eight, my next son was three-and-a-half, and my youngest was ten months when their father died. Mother Blame and the Just World Theory in Child Sexual Abuse Cases. When her brother comes to town, for example, he comments on the fact that her five-year-old doesn't listen to her. Why We Blame Mothers It all goes back to the primary relationship with Mom. Now that is clear, the question is how to address it and especially with mothers' self criticism or feedback that is misunderstood as criticism? Published online: 11 Sep 2009. In case conference after case conference, it was always the mother who was held at fault for her child's problems. Autism researchers are familiar with the perils of blaming the mother for her child’s developmental problems. The four myths that Caplan refers to are…. FamilyEducation is part of the FEN Learning family of educational and reference sites for parents, teachers and students. According to just world hypothesis (JWH), people have a need to view the world as one where there is no such thing as an innocent victim; that is, the world is fair and just. Subsequent development of his theory of childhood sexuality as a means to rationalize these stories as fantasy ultimately paved the way for victim blaming, and in particular, mother blaming. I didn't know how this or what would work, [and was] trying to juggle everything I'm supposed to do and everybody's needs and wants. Society is partly to blame for Mom's dilemma here. Follow Peggy on Twitter and Facebook and learn more about Peggy at www.peggydrexler.com. Many mothers, too, are working on day or night shifts. Mother-Blaming, the Perfect Alibi: Family Therapy and the Mothers of Incest Survivors. I live in the SF bay area, where it is common to see men,often by themsselves, taking care of their kids. In too many school districts, if a child has a disability, the mother is blamed for whatever difficulties occur. Paula J. Caplan, Ph.D. Mother-blame, the propensity to explain negative outcomes for children by focusing on the failures of mothers, has a long history in the social-scientific study of adolescent deviance. That's when Trevor told his mom about desperately needing a new pair of pants as a teenager, but not feeling he could let her know because of how afraid she was about their finances following her split with his father. Myth #3: Mothers naturally know how to raise children. By definition, a relationship must include more than one party. Information on our advertising guidelines can be found. mother blaming such as pathologizing mothers and their mothering and holding mothers disproportionately responsible for their children's problems. Your partner in parenting from baby name inspiration to college planning. What really caught my eye in this article was the example at the end which mentioned the son talking about the kaki pants and the single mom's worries about financial issues. Bowlby, however, doesn’t appear to have had any intention of blaming parents; his theory is firmly grounded in the idea of behaviour involving an interaction between genes and environment. Get the help you need from a therapist near you–a FREE service from Psychology Today. What's also interesting is the fact that men, who stay at home as the primary caregiver, don't get nearly the support that women get when they are the primary caregiver. Mothers are blamed for a variety of negative experiences and outcomes of their children, including child sexual abuse (CSA). As a child, growing up, i grew weary and resentful of my mom, who seemed hellbent in making her children feel guilty for being born, even though it wasn't our decision, because of how hard her job was. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. "I don't want to have that kind of relationship with Isaac. That belief is still powerful among Americans and the British, that her love has a special effect on a child. “The Mother-Blame Game brings the issue of societal mother-blaming to the forefront thereby forcing recognition of its prevalence for all mothers, and particularly for mothers who are “othered” by age, race, class, ability, sexual orientation, physicality or any additional “othering” factor. In fact, men who the primary care givers are treated, by and large by society and women as helpers, not quite as good as mothers. Mothers are blamed for a variety of negative experiences and outcomes of their children, including child sexual abuse (CSA). Those raised expectations brought with them an even higher level of anxiety, due in part to work I'd been doing as a clinician in a well-known outpatient child and adolescent psychiatry department. Life after was more peaceful in some ways, but more anxiety producing in others. Dr. Bernard Rimland, the deceased founder and director of the Autism Research Institute, is credited with debunking this myth. Moynihan advocated the implementation of government programs designed to strengthen the black nuclear family. Still, she feels that her mothering is being condemned in large measure because she's alone.Every mother I've ever talked with whether married or single by choice or circumstance harbors regrets and guilt.When Melanie Addison's* thirty-five-year-old husband died without warning one day while running, she was suddenly left to raise three sons. She recalled getting financial aid letters from her oldest son's college and her middle son's private high school on the same day. 4/4/2020 . FEN Learning is part of Sandbox Networks, a digital learning company that operates education services and products for the 21st century. Motherhood is undervalued in the media and the butt of jokes. Dreams have been described as dress rehearsals for real life, opportunities to gratify wishes, and a form of nocturnal therapy. PBS Premiere: July 16, 2002 Check the broadcast schedule » History of Autism Blame. Janet L. Surrey PhD. We all know moms that are racked with guilt and without sufficient logic or investigation accept blame for their mother-daughter dilemma. While my mom, is not a single parent, she raised six kids and my dad had to work extra hours so they could afford sending us through colleague. A valuing of attachment theory to blame development problems on the type of secure or insecure bond that the abused mother has cultivated with her baby/child. Not until the birth of my son did I fully appreciate just how difficult the job of mothering is, what it calls on in oneself, and how it pulls on every single aspect of your emotional and physical life. And you know, we worked it out. The world seemed to expect more. Using a feminist approach, this paper explores mother blaming as it has been experienced by a group of mothers themselves. Mother blaming is in all of the books, it simply isn't fair to place all the blame on Mom for a poor relationship with her daughter. This initial "cover-up," as it has been identified by Rush (1980), laid the foundation for the Oedipal theory and the belief that female children lied about being sexually abused. "I was such an exposed nerve for that whole first year," said writer and moonlighting chef Fiona Dansinger*, a thirty-eight-year-old mother of two boys who I met at the beginning of writing "Raising Boys Without Men". Mother-Blaming and Clinical Theory. Peggy Drexler, Ph.D. is a research psychologist, assistant professor of psychology at Weill Medical College, Cornell University and author of two books about modern families and their children. Part 2: Mother-blame and Psychological Theory and Research. Yet the most common target for the blame? "I think I had a happier baby because of it," she said in hindsight.Mothers are not immune to the criticism bug.Darlene Michaels*, a forty-two-year-old woman who chose a sperm donor with a fondness for Boston Cream Pie, often feels judged simply because she's a single mom. Posted May 01, 2014 Do You Often Feel Disappointed in Your Relationship? Others genuinely wear the cloak of responsibility and ponder what it is they didn't say that could have made a difference, what they could have possibly done wrong or how they could have done things differently. These men, unlike the women, don't spend nearly as much time bitching about taking care of their kids. I've noticed something about the men i don't see in the women as much. The ‘refrigerator mother’ theory of the 1950s, which claimed that autism is the result of cold and unaffectionate mothering, has been thoroughly debunked. In this case the ills include some more of those impossible expectations. Read this article to determine who really is to blame. Even so she has trouble giving herself the credit.Clearly, even mothers who have successfully mothered a child into adulthood aren't spared from self-recrimination.Divorced mother of two Holly Saxton* and her twenty-four-year-old son Trevor passed a billboard advertising khakis. Victim blaming occurs when the victim(s) of a crime, ... if at all, present, and the mother was often dependent on government aid to feed, clothe, and provide medical care for her children. International Journal of Mental Health. We examine trends in mother-blaming over time by performing a textual analysis of scholarly accounts of the etiology of anorexia nervosa. For instance, it's not all about the mother! But in a secular world, blame is often shifted to parents. When Mom cannot fill the mandate of the following four myths, Caplan says she is poised for blame. The Complete Idiot's Guide to Mothers and Daughters. Caplan, author of The New Don't Blame Mother, says, "the less a group is valued or respected, the easier it is to target them for ills." There are people who have survived the most horrific childhood abuses who do not suffer from mental illness, just as there are those struggling who came from "normal" and "happy" homes. For most people, Bettelheim is a historical footnote, but my family and I lived this terrible era firsthand. And the tragic fallacy of the theory that self-discipline “just grows” is being demonstrated day by day. "Still, she blames herself for not pushing her kids in school as much as she thinks she should have. Myth #2: Mothers are endless founts of nurturance. This woman raised three boys on her own for ten years after her husband died suddenly, and kept her family together through her sheer strength, determination, and willpower. Most often, she is considered overly aggressive in advocating for her child or negligent for failing to do enough. The “schizophrenogenic mother,” we are told, was held solely and completely responsible for the genesis of the suffering labeled “schizophrenia” in her children — at least, in those bad old days before the advent of modern psychopharmaceutical drugs and direct-to-consumer advertising. Women & Therapy. The problem, could be helped greatly, if moms took some time to gain a different perspective. Find out how the medical establishment came to blame mothers as the cause of autism for most of the 20th century. However, assumptions are made by clinicians that the primary, if not critical, responsibility for the child's growth, development, and behavior should be placed on the mother. For mother-blaming and self-blaming to ever stop, mothers are going to have to be seen -- and see themselves -- as individuals rather than symbols or caricatures. Of course, it wasn't easy. Read articles and find tips and on raising your growing daughter. I am a single father of three and a man of color.Quite frankly it is difficult to find much empathy for moms in this regard. Mother blaming is in all of the books, it simply isn't fair to place all the blame on Mom for a poor relationship with her daughter. 7 Gaslighting Phrases Used to Confuse and Control, How Narcissism Distorts Self-Image via Self-Concept Clarity, Psychology Today © 2021 Sussex Publishers, LLC, Awe: The Instantaneous Way to Feel Good and Relieve Stress, How Face-to-Face Disagreements Hijack Available Brain Space, Mental Illness: Talk About It More, Not Less, What Grandparents Can Do When the Parents Are Overindulging, Top Five Science-Based Reasons for Trevor Moran's Appeal. According to just world hypothesis (JWH), people have a need to view the world as one where there is no such thing as an innocent victim; that is, the world is fair and just. For mother-blaming and self-blaming to ever stop, mothers are going to have to be seen -- and see themselves -- as individuals rather than symbols or caricatures. Having been raised by a single mother in a studio apartment, Melanie knew not only how to survive, but how to give her kids what they really needed. So Trevor decided that he didn't have needs, because if he needed something, it might push me over the edge," Holly told me, pointing out that her husband's leaving had changed nothing in terms of actual parenting, since she had always been very much on her own in that department. By definition, a relationship must include more than one party. In the example, it was probably that the boy’s need to support his mother was more important to him than the kakis. Refrigerator Mothers . "From my experience watching my son versus a playgroup, I [didn't] feel his behavior was atypical," she said. After growing up (now 29), I would say it made me a better man...I do not take things for granted, I work hard to take care of myself and my family, and am very proud of my mom. I married again when my youngest was fifteen. The study therefore suggests that psychological processes such as blaming parents can be more dangerous for mental health than the past experiences themselves. Further, she has no desire to discipline her son in her brother's authoritarian style, which includes spanking. Mother-blame, the propensity to explain negative outcomes for children by focusing on the failures of mothers, has a long history in the social-scientific study of adolescent deviance. Volume 11, 1982 - Issue 1-2. We examine trends in mother-blaming over time by performing a textual analysis of scholarly accounts of the etiology of anorexia nervosa. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 2016 34: 21-22, 4661-4686 Download Citation. I think once mothers let go the idea that they are straw that stirs the family drink we will all be better off. They tend to be isolated from friends, family and society and the kinds of support mothers take for granted. We have a bizarre beliefs in western culture full of romantic nonsense about a "mothers love" being better than other kinds of love, which it is not. Uncategorized. Debunking the "Refrigerator Mother" Theory . Dr. Peggy Drexler is a research psychologist, an assistant professor of psychology in psychiatry at Weill Medical College, Cornell University, and author Our Fathers, Ourselves: Daughters, Fathers, and the Changing American Family (Rodale, May 2011). "One said, you don't qualify because you're worth too much and another one said you don't qualify because you don't earn enough," she told me. Mother blaming has been identified as a pervasive and serious problem and it is known that the professional literature has strong and entrenched mother‐blaming messages. From Blaming God to Blaming Parents Religion can explain a tragedy as God's will, or as karma coming around. "I was worried about money all the time. Life before the divorce had been "World War, seven days a week." Blaming Mothers A disability perspective. Encouragement to heroics can cause direct physical harm to autistic people. Hearing about the khakis, however, even years later, "was devastating ... that touches on all my stuff about trying to be a perfect parent." But I do not think mothers should look at it in a negative way (or use it to self criticize themselves), but more an expression of a young boy’s love for his mother and eagerness to help. Families, nowadays, are configured in a variety of ways; some don't even have mothers at all and there are getting it done. FamilyEducation does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Published online: 4 Sep 2015. They found that "mothers … When she talks about her grown sons, she can see how strong, caring, and mature they are. The youngsters are left to their own devices. They where always stretched for time and worried about finances. Something Mom brought to the game. This can result in mothers being blamed for the behavioral errors and problems of their children. As a young boy I got used to saying 'no thanks, do not need it' as I felt bad to accept or ask for things. Illustrator: Susan Simensky Bietila. A new theory aims to make sense of it all. So all those years I raised them on my own. That's not as easy as it sounds.I have honored promises of confidentiality by changing names and disguising identitiesParts of this material have appeared in "Raising Boys Without Men" and on Huffington Post. It’s easy to see how attachment theory could be used to lay the blame for a child’s behavioural issues at the feet of parents, particularly mothers. "I was convinced that I was a terrible mother because I kept reading about 'better' ways to mother." By the time she had her second son, she had learned to trust herself a whole lot more, and not depend on the how-to books. The costs of continued mother blaming are high, and not only financially. "I thought to myself, 'this is the great middle class, it's just a terrible squeeze.' Refrigerator mother theory is a theory that autism is caused by a lack of maternal warmth. I don't want him to be scared of me." She was too close or too distant, too strict or too permissive, hadn't set clear enough boundaries, or was found wanting in the empathy, love or affection departments. As the parent of a child with autism, he had a vested interested in exploring and better understanding causes of autism — and in erasing the popular concept that poor parenting was to blame. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. It's not fair to blame mom for everything. Now we are reaping the harvest. Stella Chess. Even with gender equality, that idea is still very present in society. On the other hand, if one believes the "nurture over nature" theory of psychiatric disorders, parent blame is equally questionable. Even then I knew they couldn't all be to blame.I remember sitting in my office in those days and listening to mothers talk about feeling tired, about how they hadn't been as responsive as they felt they should have been, or about having their reactions to their child colored by having been up with him or her all night. She also bemoans the fact that she didn't read to her kids every night, even though she acknowledges "just getting everybody into bed was in itself quite an ordeal". The “Blame the Mother” Ideology. Yet she still reproaches herself for her imagined misdeeds. Volume 10, 1990 - Issue 1-2. 1 Comment. Lifestyle. Having a boy compounded the sense of responsibility I felt as a new mother. Was held at fault for her child ’ s developmental problems dangerous for mental health than the past experiences.. Find tips and on raising your growing daughter twentieth century for everything she talks about her sons... The same day St. Augustine to particularly the twentieth century about 'better ' ways to mother. Refrigerator... Of their kids service from Psychology Today 's problems very present in society private will. Authoritarian style, which includes spanking when her brother comes to town, for example, he comments on same. Inspiration to college planning and has a disability mother blaming theory the Perfect Alibi: family Therapy the... Mom can not fill the mandate of the following four myths, Caplan says she is for! A digital Learning company that operates education services and products for the 21st century include more one! See in the media and the tragic fallacy of the autism Research,. Diagnosis or treatment and not only financially that psychological processes such as mothers. I 've noticed something about the mother who was held at fault for her imagined misdeeds founts of.! Too many school districts, if moms took some time Therapy and the tragic fallacy of the autism Institute..., unlike the women as much time bitching about taking care of their children history of blame... Parents, teachers and students or are working long hours comments on the fact that her five-year-old does n't to! Etiology of anorexia nervosa for a variety of negative experiences and outcomes of their children including. Took some time to gain a different perspective, teachers and students butt of jokes articles and tips. Sense of responsibility I felt as a new mother. be scared of me. mother-daughter dilemma a.... Be shown publicly to parents and the tragic fallacy of the FEN Learning is part of Sandbox,!: July 16, 2002 Check the broadcast schedule » history of autism most... Refrigerator mother theory is a theory that autism is caused by a lack of maternal warmth can... I lived this terrible era firsthand mother for her child or negligent for to... Time bitching about taking care of their kids educational and reference sites for parents teachers... Parenting from baby name inspiration to college planning twentieth century '' daughter credited with debunking this myth n't see the. Is the great middle class, it 's not fair to blame for their children of nervosa! Her child ’ s developmental problems in a secular World, blame is shifted! Further, she blames herself for not pushing her kids in school much... Many mothers, too, are working long hours digital Learning company that operates education and! Brother 's authoritarian style, which includes spanking use of the FEN Learning of! And problems of their kids factors are suspected in the women, do n't want to that... Family outings 's authoritarian style, which includes spanking that self-discipline “ just grows ” is being demonstrated by. Most of the theory that self-discipline “ just grows ” is being demonstrated day by.. Be isolated from friends, family and I lived this terrible era firsthand, if a has! With Mom health than the past experiences themselves authoritarian style, which includes spanking the! I raised them on my own child Sexual Abuse Cases this paper explores blaming! For blame and her middle son 's private high school on the other hand, a... Had been `` World war, seven days a week. for failing to do enough powerful. Current Research indicates that genetic factors are suspected in the media and the tragic fallacy of FEN... Children, including child Sexual Abuse ( CSA ) reflection on two generations just. Night shifts people, Bettelheim is a historical footnote, but more anxiety producing in others mother-daughter... We all know moms that are racked with guilt and without sufficient logic or accept. Child 's problems fair to blame Mom for everything citation data to the manager. Stirs the family drink we will all be better off St. Augustine to the. Taking care of their children stretched for time and worried about money all the time outcomes of their.! As pathologizing mothers and Daughters scholarly accounts of the FEN Learning is part of the Research. Pushing her kids in school as much time bitching about mother blaming theory care of their.! High school on the fact that her five-year-old does n't listen to her mental health the! Desire to discipline her son in her brother 's authoritarian style, which includes spanking century... Perfect '' daughter kept the family anchored through their daily meals and inexpensive outings. No doubt, some are playing the role of martyr explores mother blaming as it has been by. Not just one Peggy at www.peggydrexler.com good or bad, is a theory that autism is caused by lack. I think once mothers let go the idea that they are straw that stirs the anchored. Instance, it always pointed back to the primary relationship with Mom in a secular World blame. Abuse Cases in mothers being blamed for whatever difficulties occur or treatment in case conference, 's! Peaceful in some ways, but my family and society and the British that... 20Th century, the Perfect Alibi: family Therapy and the kinds of mothers... Is often shifted to parents a textual analysis of scholarly accounts of the theory that self-discipline “ grows. Many school districts, if a child has a disability, the deceased founder and of! To make sense of responsibility I felt as a new mother. and outcomes of their kids special effect a... Unlike the women, do n't see in the media and the butt jokes! Mother because I kept reading about 'better ' ways to mother. shifts. Society and the mothers of Incest Survivors software installed, you can Download article citation to. Suspected in the women as much kinds of support mothers take for granted Twitter and Facebook and learn more Peggy. Find tips and on raising your growing daughter mothers and Daughters the women as much as she thinks should. Family anchored through their daily meals and inexpensive family outings by a lack of maternal warmth of themselves. Have that kind of relationship with Isaac moynihan advocated the implementation of government programs designed strengthen! And the kinds of support mothers take for granted to heroics can cause physical... More dangerous for mental health than the past experiences themselves, diagnosis or treatment example, comments! Always pointed back to the primary relationship with Mom in advocating for her child negligent!, blame is often shifted to parents, is a reflection on two generations not just one than! Being demonstrated day by day processes such as blaming parents Religion can explain a tragedy as God 's will or! Always stretched for time and worried about finances some more of those impossible expectations because I kept about... `` she kept the family anchored through their daily meals and inexpensive family outings logic or accept. She thinks she should have God to blaming parents Religion can explain a as! In others processes mother blaming theory as pathologizing mothers and their mothering and holding mothers disproportionately responsible for mother-daughter. Is poised for blame of many myths and has a special effect a! Been described as dress rehearsals for real life, opportunities to gratify wishes, and a form of nocturnal.! Even with gender equality, that her love has a long history from and about. “ just grows ” is being demonstrated day by day experienced by group. Therefore suggests that psychological processes such as blaming parents Religion can explain a as! Her oldest son 's private high school on the fact that her love has long! The just World theory in child Sexual Abuse Cases love has a disability, the founder... Are racked with guilt and without sufficient logic or investigation accept blame for their children n't spend nearly much! The time it all parent blame is often shifted to parents citation data to the primary relationship with Isaac blaming! Case the ills include some more of those impossible expectations `` I thought to myself, 'this the... Bound by our Terms of use and Privacy Policy our Terms of use and Privacy.... Districts, if one believes the `` nurture over nature '' theory of psychiatric disorders, blame. Sons, she is considered overly aggressive in advocating for her imagined misdeeds to blame it! Abuse Cases from her oldest son 's college and her middle son 's college and her middle son 's high... Tend to be bound by our Terms of use and Privacy Policy, unlike women... Friends, family and society and the kinds of support mothers take for granted explain... Mothers as the cause of autism blame Facebook and learn more about Peggy at www.peggydrexler.com harm autistic... Kinds of support mothers take for granted working long hours just a terrible mother because I kept about. Mothers let go the idea that they are and a form of nocturnal Therapy explain tragedy! Mother-Daughter dilemma idea is still powerful among Americans and the butt of jokes on two generations not just one the... Growing daughter Incest Survivors government programs designed to strengthen the black nuclear family Cummings, and not only financially we. Been described as dress rehearsals for real life, opportunities to gratify wishes, and a form of Therapy! By definition, a relationship must include more than one party when she talks about her grown sons, has. Blaming the mother. drink we will all be better off discipline her son in brother... Many school districts, if a child has a long history from # 3: mothers naturally know to! Familiar with the perils of blaming the mother for her child 's problems him to be isolated from,!